Blue Star Shopping Center Got Crowded Before Its New Restaurants Ever Opened

If you've driven Route 22 through Watchung this year, you've watched the signage change almost monthly. Five Below balloons in February. A honeygrow line stretching past the windows in March. Burlington's ribbon-cutting crew posing for photos in May. It's easy to assume all that new energy is what's made Blue Star Shopping Center feel busier than it used to, and most of the roundups covering the openings leave it there: a list of names, a shrug about "revitalization."

The timeline tells a different story. By the time any of those restaurants or stores had opened a single door, a new grocery store had already opened at the shopping center.

The Reset Nobody Photographed

In April 2025, ShopRite debuted a new 72,000-square-foot store at 1701 Route 22, built while the old location stayed open through construction so shoppers never lost their weekly run. It replaced an outdated store that had anchored the center for years. The visit figures that followed provide a snapshot of the center before those later tenants arrived.

Four months later, in August 2025, the center logged roughly 293,000 visits in that single month, according to Placer.ai data cited in a NJBIZ report on the property's financing. In September 2025, G.S. Wilcox & Co. arranged $26 million in redevelopment funding for the center, an interest-only loan placed through a life insurance company and negotiated by principal David Fryer. Levin Management Corp, the firm that manages and leases the property, used that capital to keep building out space for tenants that hadn't signed leases yet.

Here's the part that changes how you read everything that came after. The center's most recent reporting shows 3.8 million visits annually, up 40.1% year over year. Divide that across twelve months and you get an average of roughly 316,000 visits a month. Compare that to the 293,000 visits recorded in August 2025, months before Burlington ever cut a ribbon, and the gap nearly disappears. The center was already running close to today's pace before honeygrow, before Five Below, before any of the entertainment tenants had signed a lease.

That's the part the tenant list obscures: the openings make more sense when read against the center's earlier visit figures.

The Order Things Actually Happened In

Laid out in sequence, the arrivals look less like a wave of unrelated news and more like a chase:

  1. April 2025 – The new ShopRite opens, replacing the former grocery anchor.
  2. August 2025 – The center logs roughly 293,000 visits in a single month, per Placer.ai.
  3. September 2025 – G.S. Wilcox & Co. arranges $26 million in redevelopment financing.
  4. Mid-February 2026 – Five Below opens with a grand-opening weekend of giveaways and kids' activities.
  5. March 20, 2026 – honeygrow opens its second Somerset County location, its 13th in New Jersey.
  6. May 29 to 30, 2026 – Burlington opens with a ribbon-cutting and a $5,000 classroom donation to a nearby high-needs school through AdoptAClassroom.org.

The later tenant openings followed the April 2025 ShopRite opening. The timeline shows sequence, not what caused the center's traffic.

What's Taking Shape at Blue Star

Recent and planned tenants at Blue Star extend beyond grab-and-go retail. According to a re-nj.com report on the center's leasing activity, recent deals include restaurant space totaling more than 10,000 square feet and entertainment concepts accounting for nearly 13,000 square feet more.

Some of that is already visible. Marshalls is relocating into a 27,000-square-foot portion of the building the old ShopRite vacated, the same structure that's also being redeveloped to make room for Burlington, so the town's former grocery shell is now being split between two off-price retailers rather than sitting empty. Raising Cane's and Sakura Teriyaki are among the restaurant deals still filling out the dining lineup, joining Taco Bell and honeygrow. Back Nine Golf and iSmash represent the entertainment push, alongside a planned luxury nail salon.

None of that reads like a center built for a five-minute milk run. Entertainment tenants and sit-down dining are bets on longer visits, which means parking that already feels tighter on a Saturday afternoon isn't likely to loosen up. If you're timing errands around Blue Star, weekday mornings still work the way they used to. Weekend afternoons increasingly don't, and that shift will keep compounding as Back Nine Golf and iSmash open their doors.

The recognition has followed the traffic too. Chain Store Age named Blue Star one of its 2026 Top 10 Retail Center Experiences, crediting the deliberate mix of grocery, off-price retail, dining and entertainment rather than any single opening.

The Quiet Half of Town

Route 22's transformation is easy to notice because it's loud: new signage, ribbon-cuttings, lines out the door. Watchung's other center of gravity doesn't announce itself the same way. The Watchung Reservation covers 1,945 acres, the largest nature reserve in Union County, and its History Trail is a 6.1-mile loop marked with pink blazes that starts and ends at the Trailside Nature and Science Center. Along the way it passes Lake Surprise and the Deserted Village of Feltville, an abandoned mill town tucked inside the park.

Living in Watchung means holding both of these at once. A ShopRite run and a honeygrow pickup on one side of town, a walk past Lake Surprise or a stretch of the History Trail on the other. Neither side needs the other to work, but the fact that both exist within a few miles of each other is a big part of what makes daily life here feel unusually complete for a town this size.

What This Means If You Live Here

The next time a new tenant sign goes up at Blue Star, it's worth looking at what came before. The new ShopRite opened in April 2025. The later tenant openings and announcements, from Five Below to Burlington to Back Nine Golf and iSmash, came afterward; the sequence alone does not show what drew visitors to the center.

That's useful to know if you're planning around the center, and it's the kind of pattern that only shows up when you track dates instead of just noticing new paint on a storefront.

Denise Torsiello keeps this close an eye on Watchung's shifts, from Route 22's retail buildout to the quieter value of a town with the Reservation on its doorstep, because those details shape how people actually live here, not just where they shop. If you're curious what any of that means for your own home's value in a town this much in motion, Get a Free Home Valuation and find out.

Work With Denise

Whether working with buyers or sellers, Denise provides outstanding professionalism into making her client’s real estate dreams a reality.

Let's Connect